SHE WROTE: Keeping It Real Addendum
Every time I write on head-hopping, infodump, or real time, I keep forgetting omniscient POV. I think it's probably because I work so much with romance writers, or maybe because I write in third limited almost exclusively, only a few stories in first person, and never in omniscient. If I don't write in it, can it exist? Well, yeah. Jeez.
Third Omniscient is when the storyteller is God, sees all, knows all, is clearly in the text. There is no real time because the Now of the story is the author telling it. Pratchett is Third Omniscient and he's a genius at it. Tolkien. A lot of thrillers like Bob's are third omniscient. A lot of nineteenth century lit is omniscient. Omnsicient is very distant, but it's great if you're an author who likes to comment on the story and has no interest in creating real time. Generally, romance authors, well most modern authors, do want to create that willing suspension of disbelief in real time, do want the reader to feel that what the characters are experiencing, he or she is experiencing. It's a tricky one to explain because of course Pratchett and Tolkien create a willing suspension of disbelief, too; I believe utterly in Death and Vimes and Susan when I'm in Discworld.
Anyway, if you're writing in omnisicent, you can head hop because the only head you're really in is the head of the storyteller god. You can move out of real time because the actual real time of the story is the storyteller telling the tale, not the character experiencing it. And while I would still caution about infodump, if you have a magic voice like Pratchett, you can give your laundry list in the story and it'll be marvelous. Pratchett even does prologues that begin nine thousand years before the story and you don't know why until three-quarters of the way through the book. Right after the first prologue, he puts in another one that happens only a month before the beginning of the book. Then the hero is executed in the first chapter, which of course has no real effect on him going on to be the hero of the book for the next three hundred plus pages. Then Pratchett tacks on an epilogue headed "Some Time After" where he ties up an annoying little loose plot thread. (This is Going Postal, great book.) When you're in omniscient, and you write like Pratchett, you can do that.
Actually, if you write like Pratchett, you can probably do anything.
But if you're writing third limited, write third limited. The beauty of third limited is that it's LIMITED. That's where the intensity and the connection come from.
POV. It's a beautiful thing.

9 Comments:
Thank you, Jenny!!
Now I can stop yelling at myself about head-hopping.
I've been writing Third Omniscient but I kept trying to make it Third Limited. :)
I love you even more now that I know you're a Pratchett fan. I've been a fan (read: stalker) for over a decade. Have you read Witches Abroad? It's not a Susan book , but it's about the power of stories. I'm convinced everyone should read it. And all of Pratchett. Over and over again.
Lindsey
I just finished Going Postal a few weeks ago and I loved it, like I do all Pratchett's work. He really just seems to get better and better, which is great for me as a reader and intensely humbling as a writer.
Has anybody read Thud!—and can I mention how that is a great title?—yet? I'm waiting for the paperback to be released, so I haven't read it yet.
Going Postal was the first Pratchett book I read in a few years!! Such a good read!
I've read it and it's FABULOUS!! I'm one of those freaks that shows up the day it's released and demands a copy.
Vimes is one of my favorite characters, and the way Pratchett handles the Dwarves and Trolls is pure magic. I meet Pratchett when he was touring for Thud! and he was amazing.
Lindsey - who's also a freak about Jenny's stuff :)
I love the Discworld books! I love Jenny's books! They both make me look at things differently (I'll never see a shopping cart the same way again, or an alligator, for that matter) that are here in the real world. Was I the only one who put Terry's two newest titles together and lost it laughing? (Thud! Where's My Cow?)
Pratchett is brilliant.
When he 'head hops', you never lose the thread of the story or have to go back and check who just said what. There are Few authors who can do that.
Thanks for the interesting post -
(And hopefully it will bring in more Discworld fans!)
Sigh. How come he can make 3rdO look so easy, when it ain't? (-; And, you're another one, Crusie, who makes 3rdL look really effortless. Thanks for letting us see the duck's feet paddling like hell underneath the surface!
Going Postal--first Pratchett for me. Actually, it was the first one I have ever seen on a store shelf! Liked the fact that, even though I had never read any of his other books, I was able to get into the story and the world and didn't get left too far behind. Now I will have to find more so that I can catch up... Great characters.
Post a Comment
<< Home